Horizons Presbyterian Church

History

1785

Presbyterian worship begins in Whitesboro

A Presbyterian worshiping community takes shape in the Whitestown area, beginning the history of what would become Whitesboro Presbyterian Church.

1793

The Utica and Whitesboro congregations share a beginning

The two communities worship together as the United Society of Whitestown, before developing into distinct congregations.

1804

First Presbyterian Church of Utica is incorporated

The Fort Schuyler congregation is legally incorporated as a church, later known as the First Utica Presbyterian Society.

1924

First Presbyterian dedicates its Genesee Street church

First Presbyterian moves into its new church building on Genesee Street, which serves as its home for generations.

2019

Whitesboro Presbyterian votes to close

The Whitesboro congregation votes to close, while its members, history, and traditions continue to be part of the church community at 1 Elm Street.

2023

First Presbyterian moves to Whitesboro

After selling its Genesee Street property, First Presbyterian moves to the former Whitesboro Presbyterian Church building at 1 Elm Street. Members of both congregations begin sharing a church community and identity.

2026

The congregation considers a new name

Members gather to discuss a name that reflects the church’s shared identity, its present location, and its hopes for the future.

October 4, 2026

Horizons Presbyterian Church begins

The congregation adopts the name Horizons Presbyterian Church, honoring the histories of both churches while looking ahead to a new chapter of faith and service.

There’s a Place for You

Take the next step toward connection, service, and spiritual growth at Horizons Presbyterian Church.